I Know I'm Going to Pay for This, But... Can You "Know Enough"?

 

I exchanged emails with my high school English teacher not long ago.  I apologized to her.

"You know that time you said, 'Don't you just love LEARNING things?  Just to for the sake of learning?'  And we said, collectively, 'Uh...what?'  Well,I get it now.  A bit late, but I get it.  I love learning now."

A little late, but there you go.  I wish I could take her class again.

Everything is interesting.  Knowledge is wonderful.  All truth is God's truth, which means we should pursue truth relentlessly in any field we like, dangit.  Anti-intellectuals in my past will bristle to find out that Solomon himself didn't just ask for wisdom -- he asked for knowledge, too.  And lo, God backed up the truck of knowledge upon him, and people came from far and wide to be freaked out by it, and they did payeth him serious jack for his efforts, and he did surpriseth all by making some right nice cabinets.

That said, it's my thinking now that most Christian believers here -- get this! -- actually know enough.  And this feller, Sy Rogers, agrees.  (HT: The brilliant Ms. Shakes, who came across this when she was doing translation work.)

Most American Christians, most first-world Christians, most well-educated Christians with bookstores and Christian Bible colleges and resources available do not need more knowledge.  If you never, ever heard another sermon and God took you and squeezed you out information-wise all over the deserts of the world, you would probably have enough knowledge in you to serve many people for a generation.

Sy is then quick to say, "I'm not saying you shouldn't study the Bible," and "Don't you walk outta here and say, 'Sy doesn't honor the word and believe in studying..."  Likely because he knows people are primed to be en garde against modern liberalism.  But he's not a modern liberal, and neither am I.

Yes, there is much to learn, and life is complex.  Yes.  But you know what?  It may be that simplicity isn't the opposite of complexity, it's complexity's ultimate conclusion.  It just may be that the most learned people, those who've fought through the deepest theological questions and accrued the most knowledge -- it may just be that they'll be the first ones to say, a la Paul Ricoeur:  There is another naivete, a second one, that lies at the far side of complexity.

It may be that, after your theological argument in a Sunday School class, your daughter, fresh from her class, meets you in the hallway with a homemade fridge magnet that's more advanced:  "Jesus is Lord." 

There is a second naivete, at the far side of complexity.

Karl Barth, perhaps the 20th century's most important theologian, summed up his work famously:  "Jesus loves me, this I know."

And "Jesus Loves Me" is not childishness.  It's not ignorance.  It is beautiful distillation.  "Jesus is Lord" is packed with deep meaning, but -- wonderfully -- children and the illiterate grasp it better than many of the learned.  It's why a persecuted church in China can thrive, even when it's theologians and pastors are in jail.  "Jesus is Lord and Savior." 

There's simply no luxury as time to argue about dense theology, and expert-culture cannot be afforded.  Now, people can "travel light", as Alan Hirsch puts it, and the message becomes transferable through relationships, not massive and expensive institutions.

Is Christianity complex?  Yes, but not necessarily.  Jesus said all the commandments could be summed up with two.  And speaking of "travelling light":  Jesus said his "yoke" -- his rabbinical teachings -- was light.

Maybe, just maybe, we know enough, but "the problem" isn't that we just need to "get fed" again and again and again, by a pastor on Sunday, and during the week by Christian publishers.  Maybe we've been fed plenty, but -- you know? -- we don't really love people.

Persecution isn't good, and shouldn't be glamorized.  But one of its by-products -- de-complexifying -- can be quite good, indeed.  Maybe our expert culture is hurting us.  Maybe -- here's where you don the gloves -- we've way over-emphasized teaching in this culture, because -- gulp -- it's working out nicely for professional teachers, and (us) professional learners.  Perhaps we're making this far more difficult, far more time-consuming, ludicrously more expensive, than a movement needs to be.

And maybe you've been fed.  A lot.   And now?

Don't hit me, but...maybe you know enough.

posted by Brant Hansen at 7:00 AM on May 18th, 2010
9 Comments   |   Email this to a friend   |  







Please enter the anti-spam code from the image above.
Preach it, Brother! Reminds of this quote from the beginning of "Ruthless Trust" by Brennan Manning;

"This book started writing itself with a remark from my spiritual director 'Brennan you don't need any more insights into the faith', he observed. 'You've got enough insights to last you three hundred years. The most urgent need in your life is to trust what you've received.'"

Time to actually live what it is we say we believe.
Posted By Seaton | May 18, 2010 @ 1:09
Greetings,

Came here to get a Bible for my buddy Bill. It would help if I knew his address! My bad. Glad that one is always available for him. I'll get his adddress.

The little church I attend has a great pastor. Dr.Berkey is gifted so that means I'm blessed. Funny how all the folks in their sixties and beyond still ask questions. These people know the Bible backwards and forwards. Yet they don't miss a Bible study or a service. Dr. Berkey always ask if there are questions. You bet!!! This leads to some really great discussion. You just can not stop learning. Some say to me,(not my fellow church goers)"I hope your fire still burns in a couple of years." I just look at all I'm in class with and think the fire just gets better and better.

Praise God!!! David
Posted By David Sawyer | May 18, 2010 @ 1:24
We are so obese in the knowledge that it makes it difficult to walk the walk. I think learning is great and I hunger to learn in everything, but knowledge with out application is like having the recipe for cheesecake and never making it, whats the point. I don't think Dad "God" wants us to be book smart and action poor. Great blog as always Brant, you sooooo are in the know....
Posted By Dhana Hicks | May 19, 2010 @ 4:07
I'm not sure I agree enitrely with the statement from Sy Rodgers about that we do not nee more knowledge. One of the things that is fading away in todays church is the presence of intellectual knowledge about what we believe and how it stands up against today's post-modern thinking. Some "knowledge" is over shared in todays churches yes, but when it comes to crucial knowledge, I think the church is just now realizing its shortcomings. In todays colleges and universities, what they are pressing into our students minds has to be combated with intellectual Christrian thinking. If someone confronts us about some Biblical truths and doctrines we have to be able to soundly and rationally answer. The emotionally based answers and common "Sunday School" answers to us no justice in these instances. A well though out logical and rational response based on knowledge is what we need more of to help combat the battle of todays modern thinking to make us look like the bad guys. A great book about this would be J.P Moreland's Kingdom Triangle. Too much non-essential knowledge can cloud, but crucial Kigndom Knowledge cannot be left out.
Posted By Greg | May 19, 2010 @ 4:45
Too many times have I been caught up in the specific details. Maybe because for many people, the specific details are what's holding that person back from God (or at least... so they say).

I'm too worried about EXPLAINING the specific details, and not worried about simply LOVING that person, and SHOWING that person who Jesus is THROUGH my actions JUST LIKE what somebody did to me.

Excellent blog sir.
Posted By Caleb | May 19, 2010 @ 5:07
"There is a road from the eye to heart that does not go through the intellect." - G. K. Chesterton

Posted By Cynthia | May 20, 2010 @ 10:33
I so know what you're talking about! Being my child's biggest teacher has made me yearn to learn along with her. Why was I so bored with all this knowledge in school?
Posted By Jae | May 20, 2010 @ 2:45
what if the power of knowledge becomes so visible we no longer need to see?
and what if when this knowledge becomes wisdom will it help others and will they listen?
is the wisdom of knowledge a foresight of things to come?
yes it is fun to learn but you gain to much sometimes it is better to just let it happen that way you can learn what went wrong or right i feel it is gods way of showing how we are like unto him.
a one inch squiggle grows on your brain every time you learn something new
Posted By nathan | May 21, 2010 @ 5:27
"There is a childhood into which we have to grow,
just as there is a childhood which we must leave behind;
a childlikeness which is the highest gain of humanity,
and a childishness from which but few of those
who are counted the wisest among men have freed themselves,
in their imagined progress towards the reality of things."

-- George Macdonald
Posted By Ricky H | May 22, 2010 @ 1:40
(Sponsored link)